5-4-3-2-1
So, about a year or so ago my friend Ben Curns and I sent a string of emails back and forth in which we gave our top fives on certain subjects.
I can’t remember all of them, but the list included top 5 movie montages (Rocky IV training sequence; Back to School studying for the big test), top 5 songs about drugs (too many to list), top 5 fictional hangouts, (Arnold’s from Happy Days or the Cantina from Star Wars) and top 5 rock n’ roll bass players (Ben Curns and Chris Seiler).
A couple weeks ago Joe at Hairshirt wrote a post asking his readers to state their all time top 5 favorite songs.
Yesterday my girlfriend Alisa posted about some of her top rock moments.
Yeah, it’s about time I jumped on this bandwagon.
This is, of course, a cliché right out of the movie “High Fidelity” and the book the movie was based on.
It is also fun and, not surprisingly, difficult.
When Joe posed the question my list of top five songs were as follows.
1) Care of Cell 44 – The Zombies
2) She’s a Jar – Wilco
3) Mona Lisas and Mad Hatters – Elton John
4) Come Pick Me Up – Ryan Adams
5) Product of DK – The Blue Van
I was lying.
I do, truly, love all of these songs, but upon further review I’ve decided that they are honestly just five songs that I really want other people to listen to.
I was trying to educate.
I was being a music nerd.
I was saying, “isn’t it obvious that I have a superior knowledge of good music then you”. (I dare any of you hum a bar from each of The Zombies three big hits, let alone “Care of Cell 44”)
So I’m going to try again and I invite all of you to join in.
Our first decision is this.
Are we listing our favorite five or the best five?
For me they are two completely different things.
If I’m picking the best songs of all time then I should be considering the broader scope of what a good song is; taking into consideration a song’s structure and tone and whether or not it has universal appeal.
However, if I’m picking my favorite songs then I can throw everybody else’s opinions out the window and name anything I want, even if its four songs by Asia and one by Tiffany.
Personally, I’m going to stick to the pop/rock genre, though you can put anything you’d like, including show tunes, you damned theatre majors.
You’re probably going to want to change these lists even as you are writing them, but that’s the fun of trying to keep your list short.
So here we go.
Here is a list of what I think are a “Top 5” of the best songs ever.
In no particular order but numbered anyway.
1) Stairway to Heaven – Led Zepplin
This is probably the most clichéd answer to the most clichéd question, but it’s got everything you could want in a rock song. Fantastic build-up, great lyrics, perfect guitar solo, possible devil worship. What more do you want?
2) God Only Knows – The Beach Boys
My girlfriend mentioned this one on her blog, and because I agree with her, was probably what inspired me to create this post.
One of the most earnest ballads ever.
3) American Pie – Don McLean
I remember when I was a kid my dad had this song playing.
I said that guy sure took his Chevy to the levy a bunch of times.
How can music make you nostalgic for a time that you weren’t even alive to be nostalgic about?
4) You Can’t Always Get What You Want – The Rolling Stones
Cool stands for a lot in rock n’ roll.
The Stones were never The Beatles, but they were The Stones.
5) Iris – The Goo Goo Dolls
Finished laughing yet?
I’ll never be caught dead with a Goo Goo Dolls CD, but I’ll listen to this song every time it’s on.
Perfect Pop.
The other ones I really wanted to put on:
Won’t Get Fooled Again – The Who; Born to Run – Bruce Springstein; Imagine – John Lennon; Suite Judy Blue Eyes – CSNY; All Apologies – Nirvana; With or Without You – U2.
Notice, no Motown, no Johnny Cash, no Punk or Raggae.
Just goes to show you what growing up to shitty FM radio will do to you.
Now here’s a “Top 5” of my favorites:
1) Hello It’s Me - Todd Rundgren
2) Happy Christmas (War is Over) – John Lennon
3) Nothing Left to Borrow – The Jayhawks
4) The Bends – Radiohead
5) Ghost – Indigo Girls
I’m cheating, but:
6)Ooh, Child – The Five Stairsteps
And finally…
My girlfriend kind of outed me as a Monkees fan on her blog, so I’m just going to say it.
The Monkees were the outlet for some of the best pop from the sixties.
They were manufactured?
So what?
So were the Beach Boys.
So, the Top 5 Monkees songs that prove they were great.
1) Love is Only Sleeping
2) The Door into Summer
3) Pleasant Valley Sunday
4) The Girl I Knew Somewhere
5)For Pete’s Sake
All right, now let me know what you think of my lists and then come up with your own Top 5s. Start out with best or favorite songs and then see what else you can come up with. Hurry up. I'll be right here.